The Rise and Fall of NBA Villains: A Look at Joel Embiid, LeBron James, Kobe Bryant, and Kevin Durant

In the NBA, athletes don’t just compete on the court—they also wrestle with public perception. For some players, they become celebrated heroes, while others are labeled as villains. The term “villain” in the NBA refers to those who, at various points in their careers, are criticized, hated, or perceived negatively by fans and media alike. LeBron James, Kobe Bryant, Kevin Durant, and more recently, Joel Embiid, have all worn this label. Yet, despite the hatred, the best of these players have found a way to turn the negativity into fuel, leading their teams to victory. Embiid’s journey, however, is emblematic of a different kind of villain—one who struggles to capitalize on opportunities, despite immense talent.

LeBron James: From Hero to Villain and Back Again

LeBron James’ “villain era” arguably began with “The Decision” in 2010. By announcing his move to the Miami Heat on a televised special, LeBron turned from the beloved hometown hero of Cleveland into one of the most reviled figures in sports. The move, along with the formation of the Miami Heat’s “super team” with Dwyane Wade and Chris Bosh, was perceived as a betrayal by many. The fans, the media, and even fellow players criticized LeBron for what seemed like a shortcut to success.

In his first year with Miami, LeBron leaned into the villain role. The hatred was palpable, with fans booing him every time he touched the ball. However, as LeBron himself has admitted, the negativity didn’t linger. He used it as motivation, stating, “no matter what was said, be it positive or negative, it’s going to do nothing but fuel my passion.”

LeBron’s transformation into a “bad guy” was short-lived. By 2012, after leading the Heat to two championships, the narrative shifted again. LeBron wasn’t just the best player on the court—he was a redeemed figure, the hero who had conquered both his personal demons and public scrutiny. LeBron’s story teaches us that even the most hated players can reinvent themselves.

Kobe Bryant: The Villain Who Thrived in Chaos

Kobe Bryant, one of the greatest to ever play, had a much longer tenure as an NBA villain. While Kobe’s untimely death in 2020 has cemented his legacy as an all-time great, it’s easy to forget how polarizing he was during the prime of his career. Kobe’s feud with Shaquille O’Neal, his abrasive demeanor, and his relentless pursuit of excellence made him a target for criticism. In the early 2000s, Kobe was often seen as selfish, a “wannabe” Michael Jordan who could never quite step out of MJ’s shadow.

Despite the hate, Kobe thrived in the chaos. His “Mamba Mentality”—a term now used to celebrate his drive and killer instinct—was, during his playing days, often seen as arrogance. The infamous Nike commercial after his retirement, where fans chant “Kobe, you suck,” illustrates how Kobe embraced the villain role while remaining unapologetic about his desire to win. Like LeBron, Kobe eventually shed the villain persona as fans grew to respect his commitment to greatness.

Kevin Durant: The Most Hated Man in Basketball

No player in recent history has seen a faster fall from grace than Kevin Durant. Once the golden boy of the NBA, Durant was beloved for his scoring prowess and heartfelt MVP speech in 2014, where he famously called his mother “the real MVP.” However, all of that changed in 2016 when Durant made the decision to join the 73-9 Golden State Warriors, the very team that had defeated his Oklahoma City Thunder in the playoffs.

The move to Golden State, a team already stacked with talent, was seen as a cowardly act by many. Durant’s decision was not just about winning—it was perceived as an abandonment of competition. For fans, this was the ultimate betrayal. Despite winning two championships with the Warriors, Durant never fully regained the respect he had before joining them. The NBA community viewed him as a villain, a player who had taken the easy way out.

Yet, like LeBron and Kobe, Durant found a way to silence his critics—on the court. His Finals MVP performances in 2017 and 2018 cemented his legacy as one of the greatest players of all time. Still, the shadow of his decision to join the Warriors continues to hang over his career.

Joel Embiid: The Convenient Superstar

While LeBron, Kobe, and Durant have all managed to win despite their villain status, Joel Embiid represents a different kind of NBA villain. Embiid, the reigning MVP of the 2022-2023 season, is undeniably talented. At his best, he is a dominant force on both ends of the floor, capable of leading his team to victory. However, his career has been marred by inconsistency, injuries, and a seeming inability to step up when it matters most.

Embiid’s playoff failures are well-documented. In 2019, the Philadelphia 76ers had one of the most talented teams on paper, but Embiid’s poor performances against the Toronto Raptors in the Eastern Conference semifinals cost them a chance to advance. Similarly, in 2021, despite being the top seed in the East, the 76ers were eliminated by the Atlanta Hawks, with much of the blame falling on Embiid and his teammate Ben Simmons.

Unlike LeBron or Kobe, who could turn negativity into motivation, Embiid often seems overwhelmed by the pressure. His injuries, while unfortunate, have become a constant storyline, and his body language on the court sometimes suggests a player who is not fully committed to the grind of being an all-time great.